The blogging resolution seems to have flagged already. But in my defence, I finally moved to my own domain. It’s been a bought plot lying vacant for a while so I’m feeling a real sense of achievement about this. Heh. Small pleasures. I’ve also been traveling. Last week, I was in Coorg and Kabini on work (yes, really) and then we drove through the Waynad hills down to Kannur on the Kerala coast. I haven’t really had time to wade through the 700 photos I’ve taken, but a few are up at Flickr.
With coffee bushes and sea shells on my mind, I had boycotted newspapers for a while so I was jerked back to rude reality on my return. A protest meet had been organised (quite on-the-fly) against the Mangalore incident on Tuesday by organisations like Vimochana, Alternative Law Forum and HHS. The turnout was smallish because it was so spontaneous. They’ve prepared an open letter to the government which is up at Ultra Violet.

As someone pointed out to me, acts of hooliganism against women happen every day in India. Yes, which is why we must protest each one that we can, especially when it happens close to home. When the BJP came to power in Karnataka, I remember many of us felt a palpable sense of fear. And increasingly, it is being validated. The fact that cultural identity is continually being closely tied to such beastly violence also means that we need dialogue on what our culture is, what it means to most of us, and how it’s changing. This is something that a statement by feminists like Sumi Krishna and Ammu Joseph points out. An extract:
We believe that the Mangalore assault was not an isolated episode by self-appointed “moral police” and their sympathisers who criminally took the law into their own hands, but that it is part of a pattern in the profoundly contested political struggle over what constitutes Indian traditions, religions and cultures. It is evident that in this instance the attackers were emboldened to carry out the unprovoked assault in a political environment that supports a particularly narrow and fanatical view of Indian culture as also a repressive attitude towards women.
And:
We strongly believe that the State and democratically minded citizens must stand up to the violent targeting of women and re-affirm our commitment to the human rights and civil liberties of all people. There can and should be dialogues on what constitutes “Indian-ness”, but regardless of the interpretations of Indian culture and traditions, the beating and molesting women cannot be condoned.
You can read the entire statement at UV and leave your name, location / affiliation in the comment space if you want be added to the signatories. We will collect them and send them to Sumi.
And here are some of the reactions from politicians. All from here.
“Women should not try to imitate men. Progress does not mean becoming males,” said Mridula Sinha, member of the BJP’s national executive. Bijoya Chakravarty, BJP’s national vice president, said in Assam that “it is not good for a young woman to go to a pub”.
In Jaipur, Gehlot told reporters: “It was being propagated that young boys and girls looked very good while going around the pubs and malls by holding their hands. I want to end that culture.”
“India is not Europe. Mushrooming of pubs is not part of the Indian culture,” said Communist Party of India state secretary Manju Kumar Majumdar.
Bring on the veils already.
Also, my post at Guardian Cif on this.
Tags: mangalore pub incident, repression, violence against women







[...] Sengupta in Bangalore writes: As someone pointed out to me, acts of hooliganism against women happen every day in India. Yes, [...]
I found your post as very encouraging and it seems something is moving, finally against this society which consider woman more as an object rather being a human, but I would like a small question here, Why was this so much uproar when some woman were attacked in a pub? Was it because the urban lifestyle was attacked for first time? Because in India we can found cases on everyday basis where woman is harassed, molested and attacked but no one take out procession when an innocent is killed because of her inter-cast marriage or rather we still don’t find an institution which can truly help a woman to raise her voice against what she suffers.
I am saying all this because I saw a ray of hope when I went through the articles and I hope something more can be done on ground because there is still a lot of difference in rights which women enjoy in cities and in small towns…
Sigh. It’s always sharp and rude and jolting, isn’t it? Reality, I mean. You must tell us about your Coorg adventures…you’re practically a local now.
Vikram: Coincidentally, I just read something on another blog that answers this and which I agree with so will point you there — http://horadecubitus.blogspot.com/2008/12/horror.html. But basically, people react more vehemently when an incident is ‘closer’ in some way. So it’s understandable that there would be lots of protests in Bangalore (being in Karnataka) and among the urban, educated section.
However, women’s rights organizations are fighting for rural women, women in villages etc. In Bangalore, Vimochana and Hengasara Hakkina Sangha both do a lot of work with them. On UV too, we have written about a variety of issues including acid attacks, gujarat riots, the problems of hijras. So I disagree that there are no institutions.
It would be great if we could all be more aware and active all the time, but short of that, it’s important to protest at least when something does cut so close to the bone.
OJ: Heh. I wish! I just love that place. But being a Kodava ain’t that easy.